I have terrible closers. I was offered this trade.

[Ravens_101]

Hey everyone, I was offered Joakim Soria and Brandon Beachy for my Adam Dunn. Should I accept ?

My team:
C: Montero
1B: Pujols Util: Youks BENCH:Dunn
2B: Ian Kinsler BENCH: Beckham
3B: David Freese Util: Jon Herrera ( COL )
SS: Yunel Escobar
OF: Kemp, Ichiro, Rios
P: Oswalt, Carpenter, Marcum, Harrison ( TEX ), Danks, BENCH: Narverson ( MIL )
RP: Farnsworth, Perez(CLE) BENCH: Franklin, Contreras

[lane_anasazi2]

Nope - Dunn's great for your UTL spot and you could get more for him. Your closers aren't great, but you'll get some saves. It would be much more profitable to mine the WW... is Padilla available? Kuo?

[smoovethug]

Looks like your league is pretty shallow. Double check to make sure there aren't any closers floating out on the wire. Hold off on this trade. Dunn is a perennial power threat who's just off to a slow start. Soria is a top tier closer, but I still think you're selling low here.

[Ravens_101]

Ill hold off until mid season to shop Dunn. Thanks guys.

[mkultra]

I disagree, I'd absolutely do this trade unless you're in roto league that uses OBP instead of AVG or a points league that doesn't penalize KO's. Something's wrong with Dunn, IMO, aside from a "slow start"- his contact rate is just abysmal.

Aside fom that, he's your 3rd First Baseman, riding the pine. He's doing ZERO for your team. Soria's a top RP who could easily get dealt to a contender at the deadline. He's definitely an upgrade over either of your current closers. Farnsworth is destined to lose his job- straight fastballs are not a recipe for ongoing success.

[CubsFan4Life23]

I think you hold onto Dunn...Great hitter hitting in another hitters park...Power is there, keep him or get more in return

help me?
viewtopic.php?t=429067