Am I selling low on J-Up?

[Ragoczy]

NL only 5x5. Offered C Coghlan & C Billingsley for J Upton & K McClelland. Looking for more K's. Just concerned about trading away too much offense and Bill's ERA and WHIP.

Opinion?

Thanks!

[SleuterBomber]

I think you are trading away far too much offense here. McClellan is a borderline WW guy and Coghlan is nowhere near Justin Upton. No way would I do this deal. I believe Upton will be a 30/30 guy this year. Coghlan won't come close.