His Halladay for my Holliday or Heyward?

[shawngee03]

the guy will take either holliday or heyward for Doc. shoudl i do it?
12 team mixed. h2h. 10 start max.

i have some good SPs. im content w them as of now. but its not every day you have an opportunity to get the best SP. and i have markakis and Bay to fill in. and it being only 12 teams and only 3 OF spots there shoudl always be fillers. but II....ive always valued top hitters over top pitchers obviously

my team
1B texeria
2B kinsler
3B micheal young
ss hanley
of holliday, heyward, alex gordon...BN jason bay, markakis
util vlad

sp
haren
liriano
sherzer
beckett
garza
marcum
gavin floyd
javier vasquez

[juliown1028]

If it isn't a keeper league, I'd definitely take Heyward for Halladay. Heyward may be a year or 2 from producing the 35+ HR, 100+ RBI people are eventually expecting out of him. Holliday is an easy write in for 25+ HR, 110 RBI, .300+ Avg, by comparison to Heyward who likely won't produce as well as Holliday this season.

If you really can do Heyward for Halladay, its a definite yes. I'd actually still say yes to Holliday for Halladay, but I'd preferably give up Heyward if it wasn't a keeper. Markakis and Bay are great fill ins.

DO IT.