Kelly Johnson or Neil Walker at 2B

[chadeboy18]

It's actually for my UTIL spot, but I was going to try and trade Walker for Kelly Johnson? Or I was going to try and get Neftali Feliz to stash. What should I try? I was thinking Walker and Ogando for Johnson and Feliz or something? Or what should I give up to get Carpenter in the deal? Thoughts? WHIR

Batters

C Buster Posey
1B Miguel Cabrera
2B Dustin Pedroia
3B Wilson Betemit, Evan Longoria (DL)
SS Yunel Escobar
IF Prince Fielder
OF Matt Holliday
OF Alex Gordon
OF Delmon Young
OF Denard Span
OF Jose Tabata
DL Josh Hamilton (DL)
UTIL Neil Walker

Pitching

SP Dan Haren
Max Scherzer
Mat Latos
Brett Anderson
Brandon Morrow
Wandy Rodriguez
Alexi Ogando
Brian Matusz (DL)
RP Jose Valverde
Mitchell Boggs
Leo Nunez
Jordan Walden

[chadeboy18]

Bump!

[iaoto]

Is Walker 3b eligible in your league? If so I would keep him due to Longoria's injury.

I would also rather trade Wandy than Ogando, but I've been in keeper league mentality recently.

[chadeboy18]

Walker is only 2B eligible, so I use him at UTIL. Im in a h2h redraft league.

[iaoto]

I think Johnson will post better numbers for this year then. And it never hurts to have more closers.

[chadeboy18]

Any other thoughts? Walker has played much better than Johnson so far, but I figured Johnson will heat up. And who should I throw in to get Feliz: Ogando, Wandy, or Boggs?

[sigriffey]

I'm not a huge Johnson fan. I think Walker could be an all-around good 2B. But if you want Kelly, I'd get Feliz out of it and dangle Boggs in the deal.

[sluggerbrewcrew]

I'd go for Johnson, ones his avg goes up he should exceed Walker. I agree with the above post about throwing Boggs in for the Feliz deal as well, and think it'd be worth it.