Who to own: boggs or madson?

[chadeboy18]

Who should I pickup: Boggs or Madson? WHIR!

Batters

C Buster Posey
1B Miguel Cabrera
2B Dustin Pedroia
3B Wilson Betemit, Evan Longoria (DL)
SS Yunel Escobar
IF Prince Fielder
OF Matt Holliday
OF Alex Gordon
OF Delmon Young
OF Denard Span
OF Jose Tabata
DL Josh Hamilton (DL)
UTIL Neil Walker

Pitching

SP Dan Haren
Max Scherzer
Mat Latos
Brett Anderson
Brandon Morrow
Wandy Rodriguez
Alexi Ogando
Brian Matusz (DL)
RP Jose Valverde
Leo Nunez
Jordan Walden

[avsfan4ever33]

I prefer Madson since he won't have any competition for the job for at least a month.

[sixer03fan]

I'd go Boggs. The difference between these two is that Boggs has won the closer's job, while Madson is filling in for the closer's job until Contreras/Lidge come back.

[5wallace]

Madson has better skills in my opinion, but has less of a chance of keeping the closer's job with 2 legit guys who are now injured just waiting to take the position back when they are healthy.

Boggs has good skills and a better shot at having the closer job for the rest of the year I think. Tough call. Boggs for the season but Madson for the short term until Contreras/Lidge come back.

Help if you can: viewtopic.php?f=26&t=428785

[chadeboy18]

I'm thinking if I go with Madson for the next month, I can snag Aardsma or even someone else for when I have to drop Madson. The Phils will likely have more opportunities, as they will win more games!

[mojoorising]

It's really close saves are hard to project just cause a team wins more doesnt mean their closer has more save opps since they could play in all blowouts. That being said I would pick up boggs since he has the chance of keeping the job for the whole year where as Madson is only just temporary. Remember fantasy baseball is a marathon not a sprint.

help with mine?
viewtopic.php?f=26&t=428795