Keep Peavy or Pagan?

[Alkaholik]

10 Team League H2H.

i traded for Utley and need to drop one player on my DL to the WW.

Which player is worth keeping on my team on the DL in the long run?

Jake Peavy, SP - CWS
Angal Pagan, OF - NYM

[CubsFan4Life23]

Well...that is tough as I had own them both 2 days ago then dropped them both...I think Peavy has the better upside, though Pagan may be the safer choice...If you can afford to, I may just go ahead and dump them both and let them be someone elses problem

help me please
viewtopic.php?f=26&t=428657

[avsfan4ever33]

I'd rather have Pagan at this point. I don't have a lot of faith in Peavy right now... he'll have to get healthy and prove things on the mound for me to consider having him on my team.

[diesek]

Never been a believer in Pagan.

Peavy will probably never be as good as he was in San Diego.

If you really want to keep one, go with Peavy.