Utley and Bay for CarGO?(WHIR)

[kidsilk]

13 team, 25 man rosters, auction league with FAAB free agent bidding. Roto league, 5x5 standard cats. Keeper league. I have been offered Chase Utley and Jason Bay for my CarGo. It is tempting but will Bay produce and will Utley be back next month like he says he will? Even if he does come back is it worth it to deal CarGo who I have a mancrush on....lol. Here is my lineup. What are your thoughts? Thanks and leave your links.

Hanigan, Ryan
(C) CIN Home: 3 (HOU)
Away: 3 (@CHC) 374 252 7% 4% 2 A 0.2195 7 2 6 0
C Mesoraco, Devin
(C) CIN Home: 3 (HOU)
Away: 3 (@CHC) 1208 940 7% 0% 2 A 0.0000 0 0 0 0
1B Overbay, Lyle
(1B) PIT Home: 3 (HOU)
Away: 3 (@SD) 211 216 16% 9% 6 A 0.2564 9 1 10 0
2B Barney, Darwin
(2B,SS) CHC Home: 3 (CIN)
Away: 3 (@LA) 653 86 32% 28% C 0.3286 11 0 11 1
3B McGehee, Casey
(3B) MIL Home: 0
Away: 7 (@ATL,@STL) 86 131 98% 93% 20 A 0.2875 7 2 13 0
SS Gonzalez, Alex
(SS) ATL Home: 4 (MIL)
Away: 3 (@PHI) 258 298 37% 24% 6 A 0.2143 9 3 5 0
MI DeWitt, Blake
(2B,3B) CHC Home: 3 (CIN)
Away: 3 (@LA) 248 307 2% 1% 1 A 0.2500 3 0 2 0
CI Miranda, Juan
(1B) ARI Home: 3 (COL)
Away: 3 (@SD) 240 302 4% 1% 1 A 0.2286 4 1 3 0
OF Ethier, Andre
(OF) LA Home: 3 (CHC)
Away: 3 (@NYM) 39 23 100% 99% 26 A 0.3820 12 2 13 0
OF Gonzalez, Carlos
(OF) COL Home: 0
Away: 6 (@ARI,@SF) 5 154 100% 98% 42 A 0.2278 12 1 13 3
OF Roberts, Ryan
(2B,3B,OF,SS) ARI Home: 3 (COL)
Away: 3 (@SD) 406 54 35% 29% C 0.3200 9 4 13 2
OF Werth, Jayson
(OF) WAS Home: 1 (SF)
Away: 6 (@PHI,@FLA) 40 231 99% 91% 26 A 0.2000 12 3 5 2
OF Young, Chris
(OF) ARI Home: 3 (COL)
Away: 3 (@SD) 50 192 99% 90% 24 A 0.2118 13 4 14 0
U Bonifacio, Emilio
(3B,OF) FLA Home: 3 (WAS)
Away: 4 (@STL) 278 173 3% 3% 3 A 0.3191 4 0 2 2
Injured (C) Navarro, Dioner
(C) LA Home: 3 (CHC)
Away: 3 (@NYM) 352 1627 1% 0% C 0.0000 0 0 0 0
Injured (OF) Blanks, Kyle
(OF) SD Home: 6 (PIT,ARI)
Away: 0 237 1697 5% 0% C 0.0000 0 0 0 0
Injured (OF) Morgan, Nyjer
(OF) MIL Home: 0
Away: 7 (@ATL,@STL) 98 159 16% 2% 13 A 0.4545 3 0 2 1
Pitchers (Learn More)
Schedule Rankings Trends Contracts Stats
Pos Edit Active Pitchers 5/2-5/8 Proj. Actual Own Start Salary Contract ERA WHIP W K S
P Batista, Miguel
(P) STL Home: 7 (FLA,MIL)
Away: 0 620 219 1% 0% C 1.174 1.5652 1 5 0
P Billingsley, Chad
(P) LA Home: 3 (CHC)
Away: 3 (@NYM) 54 120 97% 79% 15 A 4.129 1.3765 2 27 0
P Broxton, Jonathan
(P) LA Home: 3 (CHC)
Away: 3 (@NYM) 41 105 95% 86% 16 A 4.655 1.5517 1 7 5
P Gorzelanny, Tom
(P) WAS Home: 1 (SF)
Away: 6 (@PHI,@FLA) 206 224 6% 2% C 4.959 1.1633 0 15 0
P Hernandez, David
(P) ARI Home: 3 (COL)
Away: 3 (@SD) 263 170 4% 3% 1 A 0.900 1.2000 0 7 0
P Latos, Mat
(P) SD Home: 6 (PIT,ARI)
Away: 0 28 268 97% 57% 21 A 5.940 1.2600 0 20 0
P Luebke, Cory
(P) SD Home: 6 (PIT,ARI)
Away: 0 337 485 3% 1% 1 A 7.200 1.4000 0 12 0
P Oswalt, Roy
(P) PHI Home: 6 (WAS,ATL)
Away: 0 44 7 98% 86% 19 A 1.875 0.8750 3 21 0
P Padilla, Vicente
(P) LA Home: 3 (CHC)
Away: 3 (@NYM) 261 288 1% 0% C 0.000 0.0000 0 1 0
Injured (P) Cashner, Andrew
(P) CHC Home: 3 (CIN)
Away: 3 (@LA) 293 205 11% 0% C 1.688 0.5625 0 2 0
Injured (P) Kuo, Hong-Chih
(P) LA Home: 3 (CHC)
Away: 3 (@NYM) 141 335 15% 2% 9 A 3.375 1.8750 0 4 0
Injured (P) Medlen, Kris
(P) ATL Home: 4 (MIL)
Away: 3 (@PHI) 321 417 2% 0% C 0.000 0.0000 0 0 0
Injured (P) Ohlendorf, Ross
(P) PIT Home: 3 (HOU)
Away: 3 (@SD) 219 538 2% 0% C 7.269 1.8462 0 6 0
Minors (P) Lopez, Wilton
(P) HOU Home: 0
Away: 6 (@CIN,@PIT) 430 517 3% 0% 1 A 7.714 1.9286 0 4 0
Minors (P) Minor, Mike
(P) ATL

[sigriffey]

That's tough ... I am not a big Bay fan and Utley is certainly a risk. I think if Utley comes back healthy in a month then it is worth it because you are in a deep league and 2B is shallow in that sense. This is also assuming u can keep Utley.

help me out?

viewtopic.php?f=26&t=428541

[kidsilk]

Forgot to mention it is an NL only league obviously. Thanks and please some opinions.

[HOOTIE]

No way. Cargo is so young in a keeper. Even if Utley comes back big, i still don't.

[mzkp54]

I'd probably stick with CarGo. Both Bay and Utley are big ?'s to me, and CarGo's ceiling is obviously very high at a very young age. I'd stick with what you have.

viewtopic.php?t=428586

[Can of Corn]

Love cargo, hate bay, utley has been too much of a question mark. I hold on to cargo and wait out this dry spell.

[KanyeBest]

Yeah, I don't think you're getting enough for Car-Go. All three players have question marks, but with Car-Go the odds are good that he's at least a productive OF and not a complete bust. Bay and Utley could both give you nothing this year.

Help with mine? viewtopic.php?t=428597