Blockbuster Trade Help WHIR

[bois13]

Just got offered a pretty big trade and not sure what to do with it so hopefully someone can help me out a bit

I give: Mark Teixeira, Josh Hamilton, Matt Latos, and Grady Sizemore
I get: Prince Fielder, Robinson Cano, Shaun Marcum, and Vernon Wells

I'm currently in 2nd of this 5x5 head to head league

my team
C-Wieters
1B-Teixeira, Ike Davis
2B-Kelly Johnson
3B-Alvarez
SS-Escobar, Lowrie
OF-Pence
OF-Berkman
OF-Sizemore
OF-Bourne
DL-Hamilton

SP-Kershaw, Latos, D Hudson, Chacin, McClellan, Matsuzaka, Peavy (DL)
RP-Marmol, Motte, Thornton, Contreras (DL)

leave a link if you need help and ill do my best

[Can of Corn]

I think I would pull the trigger. Hamilton might not be right all year, and Marcum should pick up a lot of wins pitching for the brew crew.

[mchapple78]

I think you pull the trigger as well. YOu make Hamilton's health someone elses issue and you get the top 2B in the game.

See Mine... viewtopic.php?t=428550

[mzkp54]

I'd make this move as well. Hamilton is a ?? the rest of the year, so why risk it when you can get back some very good options.

viewtopic.php?f=26&t=428563

[theblemishedone]

Accept this trade and run.

[ckunkle]

Ya, your team improves a lot. I live near Milwaukee, and Marcum has really been pitching well so far. I think he will emerge as a very good pitcher this season. I own Latos and Marcum and I am much more confident putting Marcum out there. Prince is also going to have a huge year. Although it is tough to give up Tex, Cano will provide pretty similar numbers.

I dont think you lose much either way, but I would probably pull the trigger


viewtopic.php?t=428623

[diesek]

I would prefer Latos over Marcum. I think you're giving up too much. If you could remove these 2 guys from the trade, I think it would be better for you.

[bbreezy8]

you get the best player in the deal in Cano, Tex and Fielder arent strides apart so you arent losing much or gaining much which ever way you want to look at it. I like Marcum over Latos, who is coming off an injury and hasnt pitched great since. The only I dont like is Grady and Wells, I think Sizemore has some upside to him. He was a top 20 pick before injury and he is young and can come back from it. Try taking sizemore and wells out of the trade and see what happens

[whofox]

I like the Hamilton side of the trade. If you can stomach the injury risk then just sit back and wait for the warm air in Arlington.

One good tool for to analyze these offers is to post them at TradeBashers.com. You can input the players and league details and the users vote. You see just how many people liked one side and how many liked the other.