Kemp/Marmol for Choo/Wright?

[dans2]

Straight up would you trade Matt Kemp and Carlos Marmol for David Wright and Choo?
My 3b: McGehee
My OF: Kemp, McCutchen, Gordon
Bench: Gomes, Gardner

He also offered McGehee/Kemp for Choo and Wright? Would you do either???

My closers: Marmol, Walden, Kimbrel, Axford

[silentjim]

Tough call. Law of averages probably makes it seem like dealing McGehee and Kemp for Choo and Wright would be a good idea. Kemp will settle back down to earth making he and Wright probably about even if Kemp stays above average and most would assume Choo over McGehee is a nice buy low.

[timaxman]

I see the point in trading kemp, but if you're going to at least trade him for a #1 hitter ryan rayburn possibly, don't give him up for choo value.