Should I take This Trade??? WHIR

[RPDfire007]

10 team H2H Redraft.
Stat Cats: AVG, HR, RBI, R, SB, OBP and W, IP, K, SV, ERA, WHIP

I get: Prince Fielder, Ryan Dempster, Brandon Lyon, Jair Jurjens
I Give: Pablo Sandoval, Ted Lilly, Heath Bell, Shaun Marcum

My Team:
C-Miguel Montero
1B-Adam Dunn
2B-Dustin Pedroia
SS-Hanley Ramirez
3B-Pedro Alveraz
OF-Andrew McCutchen
OF-Jay Bruce
OF-Juan Pierre
UTL-Adam Lind
UTL-Pablo Sandoval
BN-Martin Prado
BN- Ryan Zimmerman
DL-Kendry Morales

SP-Cole Hamels
RP-Heath Bell
RP-Drew Storen
P-Tommy Hanson
P-Jordan Walden
P-Sean Burnett
P-Brett Myers
BN-Jordan Zimmerman
BN-Jorge De La Rosa
BN-Ted Lilly
BN-Michael Pineida
BN-Kyle Drabek
DL-Brian Matusz

[timaxman]

I wouldn't, lyon is losing his role sooner than later.

I also don't like lilly but don't like the trade.

[friedrich15]

i agree stay put i like your players better viewtopic.php?t=428448

[Seanyfever]

While it woudl be great to get Fielder, I think you are overpaying. I would shy away. You are getting Fielder as a useful player, and I think giving up too much depth to get him.

Help me.
viewtopic.php?t=428499

[RPDfire007]

These are the availible closers on the WW. Id be dropping lyon

Matt Caps
David Aarsma
John Axford
Joe Nathan
Matt Thornton
Chris Sale
Frank Francisco
Mitchell Boggs

[RPDfire007]

UPDATE

Just countered his offer by going

I get: Fielder, Bucholz, Jurjens
I Give: Sandoval, Marcum, Bell, Pineida.

Good on my part??? There are a bunch of solid closers on the wire thats why im shipping off bell

[timaxman]

These are the availible closers on the WW. Id be dropping lyon

Matt Caps
David Aarsma
John Axford
Joe Nathan
Matt Thornton
Chris Sale
Frank Francisco
Mitchell Boggs

You should grab boggs anyway, he has a firm grip on the role and is legit.