Competitive 12 team H2H deep re-draft league. Roster below (starting spots in brackets):
C (2) - Buster Posey 1B (2) - Adam Dunn, Adam Lind, Ike Davis 2B (2) - Brandon Phillips, Gordon Beckham, Ryan Raburn 3B (2) - Kevin Youkilis, Miguel Tejada SS (2) - Hanley Ramirez, Mike Aviles OF (4) - Matt Kemp, Sin-Soo Choo, Corey Hart, Vladimir Guerrero, Adam Jones, Jeff Francoeur
SP (7) - Jered Weaver, Francisco Liriano, John Danks, Ricky Nolasco, Phil Hughes, Jair Jurrjens, Derek Holland, Kyle McClellan, Michael Pineda, Johnny Cueto, Jake Peavy (DL) RP (2) - Heath Bell, Jordan Walden, Mitchell Boggs
I would make the trade. It looks like you can start 4 OF correct? You have Kemp, Choo and Vlad who can be considered everyday players..Adam Jones is struggling big time, and although Francouer is tearing it up, who knows how long he can sustain any of his production, its a huge risk. With this you get a solid OF to be your 4th at least until Hart comes off the DL and then still you'll have a solid OF since you can play whoever is playing better at the time. You have Lind who is knocking in runs as your 2nd 1B and so I think in the long run you win since losing Ike won't hurt you as much (and Dunn will turn it on sooner than later, that entire lineup except Quentin is struggling right now so you're fine with 1B). Hope it works out whichever way the trade goes, good luck!!