Pence/Cain too much for Holliday? WHIR

[ryetoast93]

I am in a position to trade Hunter Pence and Matt Cain for Matt Holliday. I'm just wondering if this is too much to pay for Holliday, because though he is consistent, he is not putting up monster numbers overall. Cain is a WHIP beast, and Pence has a very good chance of going 25/25. Feedback?? Be sure to leave your links.

8 Team H2H 10 Categories 5 Keepers

C - Weiters
1B - M. Cabrera
2B - Lowrie
3B - Wright
SS - Ramirez
2B/SS - A. Cabrera
1B/3B - McGehee
OF - Kemp
OF - Pence
OF - McCutchen
OF - Stubbs
OF - Huff
UTIL - Guerrero
Bench - G. Sanchez
Bench - Beckham
DL - Utley
DL - Furcal

SP - Halladay
SP - Haren
SP - Liriano
SP - Cain
SP - Hamels
SP - Myers
SP - W. Rodriguez
SP - D. Hudson
SP - Cahill
RP - Valverde
RP - Nunez
RP - Walden

[MaudDib]

Not sure I would do this. Your league is only 8 teams but you play so many positions that I would rather have the depth then the better player in Holliday and if you believe that Pence will be a 25/25 guy than Holliday really isn't that much better.