Which group would you rather have?(WHIR)

[kidsilk]

I am in a 12 team Auction League with 24 man rosters. 6x6 H2H league, keeper league where you can keep up to 6 players per year. I am in desperate need of pitching to help out and I am 1-1 on the season. I have been offered two trades recently for Cueto and Jennings(on my minor league roster). I would list my roster but I don't think it makes a big deal. Just know that I have an awesome offense with Hanley and MCab leading the way.

Here is what I have been offered:

Adam Jones,Esmil Rogers, Chris Tillman, and Fernando Rodney for Cueto and Jennings

or

Chris Coghlan, Javier Vazquez, Erik Bedard, and Rafael Betancourt for Cueto and Jennings.

Which group would you rather have or would you stay with Cueto and Jennings. Each deal allows me to stay under the cap by a few dollars and I basically have no one for holds and Only Feliz for saves. With this limited info what would you do? Leave a link and I will definitely help you out too.

[Shermanator]

Of all those players I like the long term outlook of Adam Jones. Im a fan of Cueto, I think he will be good someday. But I would rather have Jones.
But Im also not a keeper league guy. I know nothing of Jennings, except the fact that he isnt in the majors.

Good luck
Please see mine
viewtopic.php?t=428308

[timaxman]

The one thing you can know is that vazquez won't be pitching any better than he is now, so take that as it is.


adam jones/tillman isn't a bad move imo.

[aqr135]

I'd go with the first group. Coghlan is the only draw for me in the second group.
Also, Cueto was horrible in his most recent rehab start (4/21).

[joselnceldran]

for a keepr league id go with the cueto/jennings side but u might suffer short term

[KJROD20]

i don't particularly care for either but the second one is brutal. if anything, the first one is okay.

[j24jags]

I'd probably stick with Cueto and Jennings, both have a lot of upside.

viewtopic.php?f=26&t=428280&start=10

[Zain1two3]

Jennings hasn't proved anything so like the other commenter says, I don't know him. They say h'es the next coming of Carl Crawford, but they always say those things. Regardless, either group being offered to you is not good enough for the POTENTIAL of jennings and cueto so do not trade them away


viewtopic.php?f=26&t=428348