Give MCab/Danks to get Kinsler/Wilson?

[giants8307]

Hey guys,

The deal is as follows: I give Miguel Cabrera and John Danks to get Ian Kinsler and Brian Wilson. I can definitely use the closer help, but I don't like giving up the best player in the deal. I'm thinking about asking him to include Carlos Marmol in the deal. By the way, if I did do this, I would move Lowrie to short and fill in first base with Fielder.

Is this a good deal for me? As always, WHIR.




12-Team, Non-keeper, H2H, 5x5 plus total bases and home runs allowed

C- M. Napoli (C- TEX)
1B- M. Cabrera (1B- DET)
2B- J. Lowrie (2B- BOS)
3B- P. Sandoval (3B- SF)
SS- I. Desmond (SS- WAS)
OF- M. Kemp (OF- LAD)
OF- J. Upton (OF- ARI)
OF- A. Gordon (OF- KC)
Util- P. Fielder (1B- MIL)
BN- M. Stanton (OF- FLA)
BN- P. Polanco (2B- PHI)
BN- I. Davis (1B- NYM)

SP- T. Hanson (SP- ATL)
SP- J. Sanchez (SP- SF)
SP- T. Cahill (SP- OAK)
RP- J. Papelbon (RP- BOS)
RP- D. Storen (RP- WAS)
P- M. Pineda (SP- SEA)
P- J. Danks (SP- CHW)
P- S. Santos (RP- CHW)
BN- S. Romo (RP- SF)
BN- E. Santana (SP- ANA)

[BALCO All-Stars]

This deal isn't very close...McCab is easily the best player in the deal and I would pass, although I agree you could use a 3rd closer. I'd rather push Fielder then McCab.

[giants8307]

Thanks for the input! Curious if you would also find it lopsided if he gave up Kinsler, Wilson, and Marmol.

[mzkp54]

This is a no brainer for me. I'm not sure I would trade Cabrera alone for kinsler and wilson. Its a no-go in my opinion.

viewtopic.php?f=26&t=428108