Trade help please

[mrdirt73]

12 6x6 league (walks for batters, and holds for pitchers are the two extra cats)

team A gets

Lance Berkman
Hunter Pence
Jacoby Ellsbury
Luke Gregerson

Team B gets

Carl Crawford
Aubrey Huff
Marlon Byrd
Brian Fuentes

I think it's pretty close, but which side would the Cafe prefer?

[lefthandedforlife]

This is a very even trade. I think it depends on what you need. I think Berkman is going to have a pretty good season and continue to excel in STL. Crawford is seriously cold but hopefully he and the red sox can turn it around.

I like what team A gets better but your giving up saves for holds. Still seems like a good deal to me. Team A wins in my book.

Help with mine?
viewtopic.php?t=427791

[mrdirt73]

unfortunately I get B

[mrdirt73]

Anyone else have any thoughts?

[2muchchalk]

i like the a side.

crawford is enticing but u are getting nobody else.

don't do it.

viewtopic.php?f=26&t=427826

[mzkp54]

I think B gets the best player in the deal, but A gets more value overall. I'd probably stick with what you have.

viewtopic.php?t=427831