Which Side Wins? WHIR

[Xylo]

Side A gets:
SP Liriano
OF Chris Young

Side B gets:
SP Gio Gonzalez
OF Andrew McCutchen

Thanks guys!

[abrage22]

Side B

[Xylo]

Thanks for the quick response. The owner withdrew the offer and offered me a different deal. How about this one?

Side A gets:
Liriano
Ryan Zimmerman

Side B gets:
Youkilis
McCutchen

This is a pretty typical 12-team points league. Thanks again!

[avsfan4ever33]

I like side B in either proposed deal.

[pjdeano04]

side B

[footballisbetter.com]

Side B wins in both deals.

[Xylo]

Awesome, awesome. Side B seems to be unanimous. Does that mean this falls into the 'unfair trade' category? I'm not looking to trade rape anyone and want to keep our league competitive.

[GDormz]

Absolutely B favors you, but I wouldnt consider if unfair, Especially if it was proposed to you. Take the deal and feel good about your day's work.

[RPDfire007]

Side B on both trades sounds good to me

[pjdeano04]

if you're asking whether it's "vetoable", I'd say no unless there is collusion going on, which I'm guessing isn't the case.