Halladay Trade Options...WHIR

[Zhangman1]

5x5 Roto Redraft - I'm middling in most cats, low on RBI, Ks, high on HRs, SVs
*EDIT* Final offers after some more negotiating

Trade: Hanson/Cain + Gio Gonzalez + Joe Nathan/Joel Hanrahan
For: Halladay + Hellickson/Bucholz + Downs/Sergio Santos

Who should I give up, Cain or Hanson; Nathan or Hanrahan.

My Team:
C: Russell Martin (C)
1B: Justin Morneau (1B)
2B: Dan Uggla (2B)
3B: Alex Rodriguez (3B)
SS: Troy Tulowitzki (SS)
IF: Pablo Sandoval (1B,3B)
OF: Shin-Soo Choo (OF), Jacoby Ellsbury (OF), B.J. Upton (OF), Matt Kemp (OF)
Util: Mike Napoli (C,1B), Jason Kubel (OF), Alex Gordon (3B,OF)
BN: Rajai Davis (OF)

SP: Jered Weaver (SP), Edwin Jackson (SP), Matt Cain (SP), Zach Britton (SP)
RP: Chris Perez (RP), Sean Burnett (RP)
P: Brandon League (RP), Jordan Walden (RP), Joel Hanrahan (RP), Joe Nathan (RP)
BN: Tommy Hanson (SP), Gio Gonzalez (SP), Kyle Drabek (SP), Matt Thornton (RP)
DL: Brian Matusz (SP), Jake Peavy (SP)

His Team:
Batters
C: Victor Martinez (C,1B)
1B: Buster Posey (C,1B)
2B: Brian Roberts (2B)
3B: --empty--
SS: Hanley Ramirez (SS)
IF: Mark Reynolds (3B)
OF: Justin Upton (OF), Mike Stanton (OF), Delmon Young (OF), Sam Fuld (OF)
Util: Carlos Beltran (OF), Casey McGehee (3B), Bobby Abreu (OF)
BN: Pedro Alvarez (3B), Paul Konerko (1B), Kelly Johnson (2B)
DL: Ryan Zimmerman (3B)

Pitchers
SP: Justin Verlander (SP), Yovani Gallardo (SP), Roy Halladay (SP), Jeremy Hellickson (SP,RP)
RP: Ryan Franklin (RP), Sergio Santos (RP)
P: Jose Contreras (RP), Kyle Farnsworth (RP), Jon Rauch (RP), Scott Downs (RP)
BN: Alexi Ogando (RP), Ryan Dempster (SP), Clay Buchholz (SP)
DL: Andrew Bailey (RP

[Zhangman1]

BUMP...offer changed

[angels7777]

well I drafted Hanson before Cain in a redraft so Hanson has more perceived value and I probably would give up Hanrahan before Nathan, although Nathan maybe carries a little more injury risk while Hanrahan is probably a little more likely to implode at some point...

[Zhangman1]

well I drafted Hanson before Cain in a redraft so Hanson has more perceived value and I probably would give up Hanrahan before Nathan, although Nathan maybe carries a little more injury risk while Hanrahan is probably a little more likely to implode at some point...

You think its a good deal? also would you take back Hellickson or Bucholz?

Thanks

[RyeWhiskey]

Hanson/Gio/Hanrahan
for
Halladay/Hellickson/Santos

This is the deal I'd make.

Hanson = Cain (but I like Cain's consistency better than Hanson's upside)
Nathan >> Hanrahan
Hellickson > Bucholz (though you could make a case the other way too)
Santos = Downs (I don't really care for either of these guys but if it's how it goes down I'll take Santos)

[lyons595]

Thanks for your help.
I'd be very happy to give up Cain and Hanrahan for Doc and Buchholz.
The Pirates are improving but won't win enough to give JH big numbers of save chances. Cain is good but never puts up the numbers we'd all like to see, except for Ks.
At this time, Buchholz is a GREAT buy-low guy IMO.