My Holliday for his Hamilton + Wells + 8thrdpick? WHIR

[alexeroberts]

11 team, standard 5 x5 keep ur 5 best keeper league.

got offered hamilton, wells, plus a 3rd round pick post keepers (8th round overall) for holliday.

My offense right now is Napoli, Fielder, Kinsler, Longoria, Desmond, Kendrick, Reynolds, Kemp, Stubbs, Hunter, Crisp, Holliday...Martin on the bench.

what do u think?

WHIR

[adamb103]

How is your team looking? Your lineup is pretty nice; if your pitching is strong, then you have to be thinking title shot. If you're not so keen on that, or even if you think you could wait 6 weeks for Hamilton to come back without losing too much ground, its a great deal. Hamilton is a much better keeper than Holliday, who might be all by his lonesome in STL if Pujols leaves. 8th rd still yields pretty good players, so you'd be looking pretty good going into next season. Hamilton would be pretty hard for me to pass up.

Thanks for the help with mine.

[mythmade]

I think your outfiteld will suffice until hamilton gets back from the dl. Wells isn't looking too got right now but he could bounce back. Hamilton is also a way better keeper option than holliday.

If you think your offense can survive until hamiltons return, I would do it.

[sigriffey]

I would do it too ... but not so much more Hamilton. I think he gets hurt too often. BUT you would have an excellent trading chip with him and could maybe go shop for Braun.