Zimmerman+othrers for Halladay, C Santana WHIR!!

[irish158]

We keep 4 players after every year. It is a H2H 5x5. We use OBP instead of AVG.

He really wants Santana and Halladay. His offers are as follows
Trade One:
Zimmerman, McGehee, I. Desmond, Bumgarner, Arenciba for MY Halladay, Cuddyer, Jurrjens, Carlos Santana

Trade Two:
Zimmerman, McGehee, Bumgarner for MY Halladay and Scherzer.

Any info or opinions are a big help. WHIR if you need it.

My roster
C-Santana
1-Teixeira
2-Weeks, Utley DL
3-Cuddyer(3/OF), Polanco (2/3)
SS-Jeter
OF-CarGo, Bruce, Markakis, Morrison, Adam Jones, Bay DL
UT-Ortiz
SP-Halladay, Scherzer, Marcum, Narveson, Sanchez (FLA), Burnett
RP-Street, Lyon