Which Catcher?

[CubsFan4Life23]

12 team keeper league (we keep 4), H2H 5x5 (obp replaces avg)

Arencibia is testing my patience...Hanigan, Olivo, Ramos and Avila are available as well as J Montero...Are any of those guys worth more than JP or do I do without a Catcher for the time being and pick up Montero...

My Team:
Arencibia
M. Cabrera
Prado / Hill
Tulowitzki / Desmond
R Zimmerman DL / McGehee
Pence / J Upton / Rasmus / Pagan / Gordon / Berkman

Hanson / Cain / Bumgarner / D Hudson / Harrang / Garza / Kennedy / PeavyDL /

I punted saves this season, just so you know.

Thanks for the help!! Leave a link.

[MaudDib]

I would be fine with JP but I also wouldn't have a problem if you just played which ever catcher was hot. I think JP has the most upside and should have the better year than any of those on the WW. I like Ramos but until he starts full time, i wouldn't worry about him. I personally wouldn't go with out a catcher just to have a minor league player on your team. I mean if I thought Montero was close to being called up it might be a different story but i don't get the impression that he is going to be in the majors any day.

[CubsFan4Life23]

Thanks...I agree, but it is hard to swallow when JP does not play everyday even though the upside is there...I appreciate the help.

[avsfan4ever33]

I'd keep JP over those other options.

[TrippySG]

I like Avila, but I think you should entertain the option of dropping someone else and keeping both on your team. IMO, one of those catchers, if not both, will have a really good yr and you would benefit more from having both on your team than keeping a backup OF that you play once a week. Honestly, do you really need that many OF on your bench, especially considering that they are mostly "upside" players just like your catchers? OF come and go, and I am betting you could drop one of them and forget about them the rest of the season, the way a couple of them are playing Ill bet they wont be touched on the WW for the next couple weeks anyways.

help with mine?
viewtopic.php?t=427341

[yoda87]

I stick it out with JP. If you got room keep JP in order to stall with Olivo, I think I might do that if I had to make a change, C is weak all over, no one else should be making that big of a splash

[kab21]

Drop Desmond and pick up Avila. Avila plays against all RHP'ing and JP catches 3 specific Toronto starters. Add them together and you'll have a very productive catcher and desmond doesn't do much for me. He's effective if you don't have a SS but he's just on your bench.