Would You Trade Hamels/Belt for Lincecum?

[rasto21585]

So in my 20 team h2h dynasty league, I was offered tim lincecum for my cole hamels and brandon belt. I think this is a solid trade for my but i am worried that my offense may take a hit. Should I take this deal or stick with what I have. Team is below.


--------------------
20 team h2h dynasty league

c j.p. arencibia
1b miguel cabrera
2b neil walker
3b chase headley
ss yunel escobar
inf brandon belt
lf jose tabata
cf colby rasmus
rf justin upton
of peter bourjos
util edwin encarnacion
bn russell martin
bn jose lopez
bn ryan theriot
dl evan longoria


sp clayton kershaw
sp jon lester
sp cole hamels
sp colby lewis
rp jason motte
rp sergio santos
rp hisanori takahashi
rp rafael soriano
p aaron harang
p sam demel
p edward mujica
bn jason hammel
bn simon castro
bn matt harrisson
dl homer bailey
dl scott downs
dl vicente padilla

[johnlee1986]

Jump on this trade.... like right now...

You're hitting is not going to take a hit from losing Belt... at least not this year... And if you're really worried about it, you can trade Kershaw or Lincecum depending on who you like better to upgrade your bat... Cause in a 20 team league, i'm sure someone is dying for one of those arms... right now with Tim's arm you could prob get a CarGo or Adrien Gonzalez...

[rasto21585]

bump please

[Hes So Taguchi]

I would do this.

[bxshock718]

Don't do it. You have a fantastic team for a 20 team league. Your pitching is set for now and the future with Hamels, Kershaw, and Lester. Belt will be a fantastic hitter someday, and to be honest in most leagues Lincecum really isn't a significant upgrade over Hamels. In my eyes, you are a championship contender now and in the future, so don't fix something that 'aint broke. Trading away a future perennial all-star for a minor upgrade in starting pitching, something you are already set in, is counter-intuitive.