Pick up Coghlan/J.Zimmerman??? WHIR

[casem2k2]

5x5 roto league, 12 teams
r,hr,rbi,sb,obp/w,sv,k,era,whip

Should I pick up CHRIS COGHLAN or JORDAN ZIMMERMAN? or pick them both up....

if so, drop who

C Suzuki
C Arencibia
1b Fielder
2b Kendrick
3b A.Ramirez
ss Tulo
ci Ka'aihue
mi Phillips
of kemp
of pence
of werth
of V.Wells
util rasmus
util i.stewart
b olivio
b loney
b uribe
DL Morales

sp gallardo
sp liriano
sp cain
sp j.garcia
rp f.rodriguez
rp hanrahan
p s.burnett
p bard
p lowe
b pavano
b d.hudson
DL cueto

[avsfan4ever33]

I'd grab them both at the expense of Olivo and Romo. I can see why you're carrying Olivo in a two catcher start league, but Coghlan's bat is more valuable to me. As for Romo, it appears that Wilson is returning very soon, which cripples Romo's value to you; Zimmerman is a high upside young pitcher that doesn't belong on the FA pile.

[smoovethug]

Add J.Z. drop Romo. With Wilson back and not counting holds, Romo's value takes a hit.

[casem2k2]

forgot to update, i dropped romo a few days ago

[smoovethug]

Add J.Z. drop Romo. With Wilson back and not counting holds, Romo's value takes a hit.

Bard fits the same mold IMO.