Rank these Closers please! WHIR

[twistedude]

Putz
Papelbon
Thornton
Franklin
Street

[KaPluie]

IMO,

1. Papelbon
2. Putz
3. Street
4. Thornton
5. Franklin

[k.k.]

My take on it:

1. Street
2. Papelbon
3. Thornton
4. Putz
5. Franklin

[twistedude]

thanks guys, any other opinions? will return the favor

[enyouartist]

I like THORTON first, with Papelbon a close second. Thorton's K rate will help you immensely. Hudson Street should be last. Many around Colorado are betting he won't make it a full season without being injured or just replaced.

1A) Thorton
1B) Papelbon
3) Franklin
4) Putz (injury risk)
5) Street (injury risk)




What would you do here>read mine! viewtopic.php?f=26&t=426563

[tonyobonyo]

I like the top 3 much more than the other two. This is how I view them:

1. Papelbon
2. Putz
3. Thornton
4. Street
5. Franklin

Any help with mine would be great viewtopic.php?t=426559

[johnlee1986]

Papelbon
Thornton
Putz
Franklin
Street

[daveblotto]

Papelbon (still on a great team even though they aren't winning now)
Thorton tons of Ks on a good team
Franklin
Putz
Street (if he doesn't trip over the mound)

Help!!
viewtopic.php?f=26&t=426608