trade 2 injured ex stud closers for a stud closer? WHIR

[fierro33]

would u give up

nathan
bailey

for

kimbrel
jodan zimmerman

this trade would leave me with just two closers (kimbrel and hanrahan) but maybe i can find another later?

10 team h2h 5x5 shallow non keeper

c napoli
1b butler
2b cano
3b young
ss hanley
of heyward
of ellsbury
of stubbs
util lind

granderson
vlad
neil walker
arencibia

halladay
ubaldo
hamels
billingsly
colby
pineda
wood

nathan
bailey
hanrahan

[lane_anasazi2]

Interesting. That's a gamble, but I think I'd do it. Bailey and Nathan both have injury question marks, and Kimbrel looks like he's closing full time, plus he just looks nasty. Zimerman isn't just a throw-in, either - he could have a quietly useful year. It's close, but I think I'd go for it.

[fantasybaseballking]

nathan
bailey

for

kimbrel
jodan zimmerman

Hmmm, I agree, it is indeed interesting. Your SP is already solid, so Zimmerman wouldn't really help all that much. And while Kimbrel has a tight hold on the job now, anything can happen and Venters could end up as closer any time now.

Instead, could you try to get an upgrade at 1B? Then move Butler into UT spot and Lind to the bench. You can try this with OF as well.

If you go ahead with the original deal, I'd suggest looking into a WW closer...is Jordan Walden still out there?

Good luck!