Pujols group or Braun/Mauer group of players?

[taw856]

On pure value and without regard to positional considerations, which group of players would you rather have in a 12-team h2h league: ... ?

GROUP A
Geovany Soto
Albert Pujols
Rickie Weeks
Alfonso Soriano

GROUP B
Joe Mauer
Jason Bartlett
Ryan Braun
Aaron Hill

[Skimo77]

Group A quite easily in my book.

[fantasybaseballking]

GROUP A
Geovany Soto
Albert Pujols
Rickie Weeks
Alfonso Soriano

GROUP B
Joe Mauer
Jason Bartlett
Ryan Braun
Aaron Hill

Pujols > > Braun
Weeks > > Hill
Mauer > > Soto
Soriano = Bartlett

So basically, Group B only has Mauer over Soto. Otherwise, I'd call it a draw between Soriano and Bartlett. While Braun is a stud, Pujols is Pujols, Albert.

Group A.

Good luck!

[enyouartist]

GROUP A
Geovany Soto
Albert Pujols
Rickie Weeks
Alfonso Soriano

GROUP B
Joe Mauer
Jason Bartlett
Ryan Braun
Aaron Hill

Pujols > > Braun
Weeks > > Hill
Mauer > > Soto
Soriano = Bartlett

So basically, Group B only has Mauer over Soto. Otherwise, I'd call it a draw between Soriano and Bartlett. While Braun is a stud, Pujols is Pujols, Albert.

Group A.

Good luck!

I AGREE WITH THE RANKING ABOVE.





What would you do here>read mine! viewtopic.php?f=26&t=426563