Drop John Buck for J.P.Arencibia??

[brianrapp]

Posada is my starting catcher either way.. Buck was an all star last year has a history of hitting for power and already belted a grand slam.. Arencibia just has tremendous upside and as my #2 catcher if he only plays 3 out of 5 games all season he could still do what i would need from him.. Thoughts??

[unkle]

i'd stick with what you got. arencibia stilla rookie and he can hit a rookie wall. also like you said hes not going to play everyday. the marlins paid buck quite a bit to hit homers and catch

[brianrapp]

Touche salesman.. When you put it in those terms it seems like a ridiculous question haha

[smoovethug]

With this being your backup C, I'd go for the higher upside play which is Arencibia.