Offered J Upton, need quick help!! WHIR

[dubstar]

I was offered J Upton/Jurrjens for Hanson. Should I accept, or counter with Shields or J Zimemrman instead of Jurrjens? I am big on Hanson this year, but really like the idea of getting Upton and maybe moving Ethier for another starter at some point. Hitting over pitching right? I would drop Abreu and grab either Drabek or Wood.

12 team h2h
OPS, R, HR, RBI, SB, K
W, SV, K, ERA, WHIP, QS

C Soto
1b Dunn
2b Walker
3b Longoria
SS Ramirez
OF Cruz, Ethier, BJ Upton
UTIL Abreu
BN Tabata, Raburn

SP Hernandez, Hanson, Lilly, Wandy, Floyd, Kuroda, Lowe
RP Thornton, Perez, Hanrahan

[Kafka]

Don't think about Jurrjens - he's for the WW - Upton is the centre-piece of this trade and is clearly the best player in this trade...he's a top 10 OF... I would do it in a heartbeat...

and good thinking with moving Ethier- he will have a good name value (overvalued this season)

[dubstar]

Don't think about Jurrjens - he's for the WW - Upton is the centre-piece of this trade and is clearly the best player in this trade...he's a top 10 OF... I would do it in a heartbeat...

and good thinking with moving Ethier- he will have a good name value (overvalued this season)

So should I try to get Shields or Zimmerman instead of Jurjjens, or do it for Jurrjens then hope for the best?

[Kafka]

J.Zimmermann- he's an injury-prone but could be a good P to add, so Zimmermann over Shields imho (but they are pretty equal).

bust honestly I would make the deal as fast as I could before the other gus realize his "mistake"

[dubstar]

Made the deal for Upton/Zimmerman!

[Kafka]

Made the deal for Upton/Zimmerman!

congratulation!