Give Up Quentin For Werth?

[Ftown]

Logic says yes, gut says no.

[avsfan4ever33]

I'd make this deal in a heartbeat. I value Werth a lot more than Quentin.

[lane_anasazi2]

Don't let all the offseason eyeball rolling about that huge contract and the move to WAS affect you too much. His contract doesn't mean anything in a fantasy league, and while park factors are important you're talking about a couple HR a year. He's got a better-than-you-realize lineup around him, and he's a 5-category threat. Quentin is a much more one or two dimensional hitter. Jump on this.

Take a look at mine?

viewtopic.php?f=29&t=426171

[Jungy69]

I have to agree with people on the boards here, though I am a Quentin owner myself. Werth is way more consistent and isn't a walking injury risk. Werth is just a proven commodity while Quentin still has to prove it to me.

viewtopic.php?t=426195
When you get a chance.

[swyck]

Logic says yes, gut says no.

You need to stop listening to that gut.

[Kafka]

Logic says yes, gut says no.

You need to stop listening to that gut.

lol


go with Werth.........

[TexArcher]

I have Werth and I wouldn't trade him for two Carlos Quentins. Guy's missed a ton of games without cracking .250 the past two years. A hot spring and a good couple of games doesn't change that.

[unkle]

i'd do it. like other people said werth can get you SBs and other hitting stats whereas quentin has pop and nothing else WHEN hes healthy althouhg i like chicagos lineup this year. but werth will get his chances on the road and hes been more consistent

[The Artful Dodger]

I like Quentin, but Werth's production is much safer (and so is his health).

[Guzman24]

I like Quentin, but Werth's production is much safer (and so is his health).

Werth for sure.

viewtopic.php?t=426259