Thoughts on this trade? (WHIR!!!)

[dynas7y]

ESPN Standard 5x5 H2H Scoring
10 Teams
Start:
C, 1B, 2B, 3B, SS, 1B/3B, 2B/SS, OF, OF, OF, OF, OF, UTIL, Nine pitcher spots, Three bench spots

My Team:

C - Brian McCann
1B - Miguel Cabrera
2B - Brandon Phillips
3B - Ryan Zimmerman
SS - Elvis Andrus
2B/SS - Aaron Hill
1B/3B - Mark Reynolds
OF - Matt Kemp
OF - Andrew McCutchen
OF - Rajai Davis
OF - Travis Snider
OF - Peter Bourjos
UTIL - Jose Tabata

P - Yovani Gallardo
P - Jered Weaver
P - Brett Anderson
P - Jhoulys Chacin
P - Tim Stauffer
P - Edwin Jackson
P - Huston Street
P - Carlos Marmol
P - Jonathan Broxton
BN - Edinson Volquez
BN - Brandon Beachy
BN - Kyle McClellan
DL - Zack Greinke

The Trade:

I Give:

Brian McCann
Rajai Davis
Carlos Marmol
Zack Greinke

I Get:

Justin Upton
Matt Wieters

Thoughts? Leave a link and I WHIR. Thanks.

[footballisbetter.com]

I say no way

Big downgrade at catcher and would really hurt your pitching staff.

viewtopic.php?t=425656

[RASportsnut]

Not just no, but HELL no!

Help with mine? viewtopic.php?t=425692

[dynas7y]

What do you guys think if Greinke is removed from the deal?

[baseballcrazy]

Even without Greinke I'd say no. I still think you'd be giving up too much. Weiters is a HUGE downgrade from McCann. I know he's supposed to "breakout" any year now but with McCann you've got a sure thing. Marmol, though at times unpredictable is still good for atleast 35 saves this year with a ton of K's. And considering you only have one other closer on your roster, your saves column would take a big hit.

Help with mine? viewtopic.php?t=425675

[tripleb]

Upton doesn't do a lot for you. You are trading for him like he is top 10 talent. U lose out on catcher and downgrade at saves, steals, and sp. Keep what u have.