Of that list, Wallace, LaPorta, Barton, Smoak, Rolen, Wigginton, and Headley have the potential to be decent CI.
Do you have any other categories or is it 5x5? For example if you count OPS or something then Reynolds gets a bump, but if you count K's you can probably drop him right now.
For now, I'd roll with Huff at 1B and the Kila Monster at CI, but don't be afraid to ride the hot hand. Of the above options, you just know that one or more of them is going to have a good year.