Justin Upton for Markakis AND Romero??

[fightcapons2011]

I need an upgrade at OF.

Is Justin Upton a good trade for Markakis and Romero?

[MaudDib]

I assume you are offering this deal and trying to get Upton. If so, then you aren't giving enough. Both of the guys you are giving up are lower tier players with limited upside where Upton has top 10 upside and many people still believe that he will reach that upside.

[fightcapons2011]

I assume you are offering this deal and trying to get Upton. If so, then you aren't giving enough. Both of the guys you are giving up are lower tier players with limited upside where Upton has top 10 upside and many people still believe that he will reach that upside.

Actually no, this was offered to me. So, anyone else have any thoughts?

[footballisbetter.com]

If you have the SP depth and don't really need Romero or could find a decent WW replacement, then I say yes...accept the deal.

[MaudDib]

I assume you are offering this deal and trying to get Upton. If so, then you aren't giving enough. Both of the guys you are giving up are lower tier players with limited upside where Upton has top 10 upside and many people still believe that he will reach that upside.

Actually no, this was offered to me. So, anyone else have any thoughts?

Then I would take that deal easily.

[avsfan4ever33]

Great deal for you on value/potential alone.

[fightcapons2011]

Great deal for you on value/potential alone.

Sweet. Thanks everyone. Its a done deal...