What do you think? Scale of 1-10. Thanks!!

[th3shuck]

Be honest!! I can take criticism!! What would you say this team is on a scale of 1-10. This is a 10 team league. Categories are traditional yahoo sports scoring + total bases. Standard pitching categories + blown saves for relief pitchers.

Thanks guys!!!

HR, R, RBI, SB, AVG, TB and W, ERA, K's, WHIP, SV, BS

C Buster Posey(SF - C,1B)
1B Prince Fielder(Mil - 1B)
2B Neil Walker(Pit - 2B,3B)
3B Michael Cuddyer(Min - 1B,3B,OF)
SS Hanley Ramírez(Fla - SS)
OF Shin-Soo Choo(Cle - OF)
OF Mike Stanton(Fla - OF)
OF Jacoby Ellsbury(Bos - OF)
Util Justin Morneau(Min - 1B)
Util Billy Butler(KC - 1B)

BENCH
Denard Span(Min - OF)
Juan Uribe(LAD - 2B,3B,SS)


Pitchers


START Félix Hernández(Sea - SP)

START Cole Hamels(Phi - SP)

START Shaun Marcum(Mil - SP)

START Jonathan Papelbon(Bos - RP)

START Huston Street(Col - RP)

START Ryan Dempster(ChC - SP)

START Daniel Hudson(Ari - SP)

START Hiroki Kuroda(LAD - SP)

Bench
Jaime García(StL - SP)
Jeremy Hellickson(TB - SP,RP)
Johnny Cueto(Cin - SP)
Jhoulys Chacin(Col - SP,RP)

[PinStripe Pride 718]

thanks for the help with mine i hope to hear from you on all my postings during the year

infield-9
outfield-8
util-9 if healthy
sp-7
rp-9 if they still can be dominate
team-8

[mister_jay_peg]

IF is 8. Not sold on Cuddy or Walker. (Like Walker, just not a ton).
OF is a 9 if Ellsbury is back on track. 6 if not.
Your 2 Util are solid, but overall, lot of 1B. (I know Uribe backs up all other IF, but I don't trust him in Chavez they way I would have in SanFran)
So your bench/Util gets a 6. (Saved by Morneau)

SP is a 10+. Dempster is under-rated, Hellickson and Chacin and Hudson can all be studs, and Felix/Hamels/Marcum is a VERY solid 1-2-3 punch.

RP, I would personally say is your weakest point, give them a 5. Street can't seem to stay healthy, and watching him this spring (life-long Rockies fan) every pitch is on a flat plane. With Lindsrtom behind him, he may not close all season. And I love Paps, but if he gets traded out of Boston (very likely with them having Bard/Jenks in front of him)

So overall, I'd give it a strong 8+. But the bench needs work, and the RP does, too. Maybe drop Garcia for a top-level MR who'll step in for saves at some point (think MIL, FLA, HOU)

Help on mine?

http://www.fantasybaseballcafe.com/forums/viewtopic.php?f=29&t=425272

[arcticrogue]

I think your starting pitching is very good. I'd give it a 8

Your relief pitching could be good.. but some question marks exist... I'd give it a 6

Your OF is solid - just need good production out of Ellsbury... give it an 7

Your IF is solid at 1B and SS. I am not sold on 2B and 3B. ... give it a 5

UTIL - Love those guys... some question on health and breakouts and the fact they both play 1B... give it an 7


Overall, I'd give the team 6.5 to 7 out of 10. I feel I am being very critical here with a score of 10 being the perfect team...

You have a solid team to compete this year...

[Padres Fan]

Thanks for the help
HITTERS GREAT OFFENSE ONLY WEAKNESS IS 3B, IF YOU CAN GET ANOTHER 3B AND MOVE CUDDYER TO THE BENCH THAT WOULD MAKE YOUR TEAM EVEN MORE AWESOME, TRY SELLING PEOPLE ON DANIEL HUDSON PRIOR TO SEASON FOR SOMEONE LIKE PEDRO ALVAREZ OR DAVID FREESE, BEFORE THEY SEE THAT HE ISN'T A SUB 3.00 PITCHER
C Buster Posey(SF - C,1B) I don't think he is the super star he is yet, but a .28015-20 season is still great at his position
1B Prince Fielder(Mil - 1B) Expect a monster power year heading inot fee agency
2B Neil Walker(Pit - 2B,3B) alot of people are ignoring him, im seeing atleast .280 20hrs 10sb
3B Michael Cuddyer(Min - 1B,3B,OF) Wouldn't be my choice as a starter, I feel he is more suited to a Bench spot for me
SS Hanley Ramírez(Fla - SS) #2 fantasy stud
OF Shin-Soo Choo(Cle - OF) I feel he is a top ten player
OF Mike Stanton(Fla - OF) .260 30hrs is where I see him this season
OF Jacoby Ellsbury(Bos - OF) Needs to prove to stay healthy, but a great .280 10hr 40sb
Util Justin Morneau(Min - 1B) If he can stay healthy hi is awesom
Util Billy Butler(KC - 1B) Great Utility pick, his AVG helps offset some of the bad hitters on the club, and some of his doubles could clear the fence

BENCH
Denard Span(Min - OF) great pick for the bench
Juan Uribe(LAD - 2B,3B,SS) never did understand his allure beside position eligibility and his slight pop, but his other #'s are too inconsitent


Pitchers OVERALL A GREAT STAFF, COULD USE ON OTHER THE STARTERS TO SHORE UP OFFENSE BENCH, AND MAYBE A BACK UP CLOSER
SP Félix Hernández(Sea - SP) CY Young but needs the wins in Fantasy
SP Cole Hamels(Phi - SP) #1 on most teams
SP Shaun Marcum(Mil - SP) A great #3 or 4 in FANTASY BASEBALL
RP Jonathan Papelbon(Bos - RP) I see him rebounding since now they got in house competition
RP Huston Street(Col - RP) could be excellent, could get hurt, could implode in Coors
P Ryan Dempster(ChC - SP) I don't like his ERA/WHIP stats
P Daniel Hudson(Ari - SP) I think he is valued too high
P Hiroki Kuroda(LAD - SP) decent complement pitcher

Bench
Jaime García(StL - SP) should develop a little more to a 16 win 3.50 pitcher
Jeremy Hellickson(TB - SP,RP) could hiccup in his first full season (but then so did David Price)
Johnny Cueto(Cin - SP) if only he could stay healthy and consitent
Jhoulys Chacin(Col - SP,RP) could be the wild card pitcher this year

[mzkp54]

I like this team alot. I'd probably give it an 8.5/10. Trade for a better 3B and I think you'll have a pretty smooth season. Solid pitching and OF, good balance of power and speed. Definitely playoff potential

viewtopic.php?t=425303

[Xylo]

Great team. I'd probably give it an 8/10. It's a solid lineup top-to-bottom, but you could really use a 3B upgrade. As someone above me said, if you could work out a deal to bring in a real third baseman, your team would look a lot better.

Your pitching is pretty good too. I'm not sold on your closers though. Paps is alright, but I've never trusted Street. The guy just plain scares me.

[Crawfish44]

Fantastic team!!!

[northjersey78]

I give the offense an 8, pitching a 7. Some question marks at relief pitcher but you have some high upside guys as starters.

Check me out:

viewtopic.php?f=29&t=425937

[goldy5000]

sounds like a epic team please help with mine viewtopic.php?t=425939 sorry I was no help i am new to fantasy and
i took 3 years off from watching and following baseball