TRADE OFFERED? encarnacion or bay??? WHIR

[ratking20]

5X5 12 TEAM ROTO

WHO WOULD U RATHER HAVE?

[ckunkle]

Joke?

I guess I would rather have a top 25-30 OF than a top 25-30 3B...
There HAS to be someone better at 3B in your wire and probably not anyone better than bay


viewtopic.php?t=425166

[ratking20]

deep league, we start 5 outfielders, CI, MI, 2 UTIL.
i have encarnacion, was offered bay, theres contracts involved but besides that....
bay seems like the easy choice but encarnacion had 21 homers last year in like 330 abs, healthy all year thats close to 40 homers, and bay didnt look too good even b4 he was hurt last year.

[ryetoast93]

Yeah tough deal here. It seems as if you should go Bay, but in the world of what have you done for me lately, he hasn't done much. Plus he's injury prone. On the other side, Encarnacion has been a steady source of power when he gets his ABs. I like Encarnacion here, I just have an inkling that Bay won't help you as much as you think he will.

Help on mine??
http://www.fantasybaseballcafe.com/forums/viewtopic.php?t=425292