How are these trade? WHIR

[khann0n]

I gave Justin Upton, I got Gordan Beckham, Jordan Zimmermann, Magglio Ordonez.
I gave Josh Hamilton, I got Corey Hart and Eric Hosmer


20 team dynasty league, basically no shot at winning it this year.
6x6 with BB and Holds

My Team
Santana
Huff
Sanchez
Valencia
Infante
Hamilton
Jackson
Quentin
J Upton
Youk
Bench - Vicienco, Kalish, Myers, Norris, Kinpis

SP - Price, Cecil, Lilly, Coke
RP - Venters, Contreras, Farnsworth, Feliciano, Mujica
Bench - Martin Pere, Banuelos, Delgado

[hot4tx]

I'd rather give up a more veteran player than Upton. Its like you're giving up a guy with lots of potential (Upton) to get a guy with lots of potential (Beckham). Youk just turned 32. If I were rebuilding I'd see if I couldn't get Beckham plus another very good young talent (Heyward, Pence, Bruce?) for Youk and leave Upton on the team.

Help with mine if you get a chance

[khann0n]

Upton was my only way of getting both Beckham and Zimmermann. Hamilton would've only netted me one of them and Granderson. I didn't like giving away Upton, but to get the deal done it had to be him. Originally the plan was to move Youk, Hamilton and maybe 1 or two more to get an established guy and a top prospect but the league has been tough with trading. Got some other moves on the block that I could post for opions...

[khann0n]

Updated with newest trade.

[avsfan4ever33]

Not a huge fan of either deal, honestly. The first one seems better to me than the second, as I like Beckham and Zimmerman as young pieces you got in return. I don't like the second deal at all for you - even with Hamilton's injury risks, you should have netted a better return IMO.