Hanley,Borbon, Maggs for Fielder.Young, Davis...WHIR

[healyja]

So I have the option of Fielder/Teixeria or Chris Young/Stubbs and Rajai Davis will be included as well.

I am thinking of going with Fielder and Young. Davis is in all trades but the owner is giving me the option of Fielder or Teixeria and Stubbs or Young.

I was wondering what you guys all thought the best options were. 10 Team Mixed Roto Auction extra cats OPS and QS.

C-Mcann
1B-Lee
2B- S-ROD
SS-Tulowitzki
3B-Youk
MI-Hanley
OF-Pence
OF-Bautista
OF-Maggs
OF-Borbon
OF-Snider
Util-Ortiz
Bench-KA'AIHUE
Bench-Tejeda(dropping for alex gordon)

SP-Carp
SP-Weaver
RP-Thorton
RP-Putz
P-Dempster
P-Oswalt
P-Billingsley
P-Myers
P-Venters
B-Chapman droping for Rauch
B-Vasquez

[sigriffey]

Personally, I would take Teixeira and Stubbs.

Like Teix in that lineup.
Like Stubbs in that Cin lineup and another year under his belt.

Don't trust Chris Young at all ... the potential for a .230 average is just not what I'd want to deal with.

[bags1107]

I like Teixeira/Young...Teixeira is 30HR-100RBI every season and plays in a left side hitting band box...Tex has been working twice as much on his left sided hitting this spring and should improve from that side...I'm not taking anything away from Prince, but Tex is a switch hitting beast!

[rukus9]

I would go with Fielder and Young. This should be an up year for Fielder and Young could be a 30/30 guy this year.

[sinicalypse]

If it's a non-keeper situation, i'd take Fielder and Stubbs, namely cuz of Fielder's contract year and the fact he's going to want to showcase the goods. Otherwise, for the long term I don't tend to trust fat guys.

If it's a keeper, i'd go with Teixeira and Stubbs... I like Stubbs over Young cuz Young has showed some wild fluctuations and sure he could be a 30/30 guy, if not a 20/20 guy, but your batting average will take a hit... granted, Stubbs wasn't setting the world on fire early last year, but he picked up the pace after having an awful average early... I'd go with him there.

[healyja]

Non Keeper, I guess I should get back to the question is this a good deal for me in trading hanley or should I keep both stud SS?

[mojoorising]

thanks for the help with mine. I would go tex and stubbs, tex you u know what you are going to get and with stubbs i like his upside potential a lot and could be a big time producer.