12-Team Auction, think I cleaned up, WHIR

[bspel55]

So here's the damage, standard ESPN. Just drafted and I wanted thoughts. I know Lidge is hurt which is why I have 3 closers, I'll work another starter into the rotation.

C - Miguel Montero
1B - Justin Morneau
2B - Martin Prado
3B - Miguel Tejada
SS - Jimmy Rollins
MI - Howie Kendrick
CI - Derrek Lee
OF - Juan Pierre
OF - B.J. Upton
OF - Delmon Young
OF - Brett Gardner
OF - Denard Span
Util - Rafael Furcal

SP - Ubaldo Jiminez
SP - Chris Carpenter
SP - Dan Haren
RP - Andrew Bailey
RP - J.J. Putz
P - Josh Johnson
P - David Price
P - Johnathan Sanchez
P - Brad Lidge

BN - Lance Berkman
BN - Ricky Romero
BN - Mark Buehrle

Thanks for taking a look and if you wanna link me I'll rate your next. Thanks again!

[Lsquad]

First off, Great pitching. Its deep, and soild top to bottom. It had better perform though, because your hitting is sub-par. You have no elite hitters- I don't think any of your bats are top five at their position, and Tejada just doesn't work as a starting third baseman. the weak offense will hurt, and i'm not sure the pitching is good enough to cover for it. I'm sorry to say that I don't think this team will be competitive.



Here's mine: viewtopic.php?t=424792

[bspel55]

Will rate yours just as soon as I finish this post.

I forgot to clarify by saying this is a H2H league which is why I drafted how I did. Basically, I will win the pitching categories every week because while 1 pitcher may have a bad start, it is impossible that all of them will fail to outduel their opponents.

As for the hitting, I really only looked for decent batting average and speed. Why? Because if I win pitching and SB or BA every week, winning record + playoffs + championship. And it's not like I won't be able to improve with some up and comers over the course of the year right?

I think the H2H mentality really clarifies exactly what I was going for in picking the team, but thank you for your constructive comments.