Holliday-Halladay Trade

[thatonekid343]

10 team H2H 7x7 (AVG., HR, R, RBI, SB, TB, OPS.; W, L, Ks, ERA, WHIP, SV, QS)
Should I do this trade?

I give:
SP Roy Halladay, SP Brandon Morrow, OF Travis Snider

I get:
OF Matt Holliday, SP Clay Buchholz

Here is my team:
C. Miguel Montero
1B. Paul Konerko
2B. Dustin Pedroia
3B. Evan Longoria
SS. Elvis Andrus
OF. Matt kemp
OF. Andrew McCutchen
OF. Shane Victorino
UTIL. Pedro Alvarez
BN. Travis Snider
BN. Vernon Wells
------------------------------------------
SP. Roy Halladay
SP. Jered Weaver
SP. Dan Haren
SP. Jonathan Sanchez
SP. Brandon Morrow
SP. Gio Gonzalez
SP. Tim Hudson
RP. Heath Bell
RP. Craig Kimbrel

[avsfan4ever33]

I'm not a fan of the deal for you. Your outfield looks fine to me, so I don't see a pressing need for Holliday. Your staff is solid, but Halladay is the captain steering that ship, so I wouldn't look to move him.

[CGHitman14]

Agreed with the previous poster. Your OF is solid as it is. Without Halladay, you don't have that #1, just a #1A.

viewtopic.php?t=424609

[baseballfan89]

Yea your team looks good before the trade, and you don't need to get rid of Hallladay to get Holliday. I wouldnt go through with this one.

http://www.fantasybaseballcafe.com/forums/viewtopic.php?t=424656

[kab21]

remove the Morrow/Buchholz part of the equation and I like the trade for you.