Should I take this trade where I give up Jeter

[birdbrains]

I was offered Clay Buccholz and Jhonny Peralta for Derek Jeter ... and another player that of my choice that I would have to drop...This offer doesnt jump out at me...but I am always blind to trades that are offered to me anyway...I do know that Buccholz got shelled a few days ago as that may be why the other mgr wants to pull the trigger plus I have 2 quality SS, with Jeter being the better one, even though he is at the end of his career and this is a keeepr league

18 team H2H league 10 keepers...no limit time on keepers
Batters Stat Categories: Runs (R), Hits (H), Home Runs (HR), Runs Batted In (RBI), Stolen Bases (SB), Batting Average (AVG), On-base + Slugging Percentage (OPS)
Pitchers Stat Categories: Wins (W), Saves (SV), Strikeouts (K), Holds (HLD), Earned Run Average (ERA), (Walks + Hits)/ Innings Pitched (WHIP), Quality Starts (QS)


c - AJ Pierzynski
1b -Carlos Pena
2b -Aaron Hill
3b -Michael Young (keeper)
ss Derek Jeter (keeper)
lf - Carlos Lee(1st base) (keeper)
cf -Shane Victorino (keeper)
rf - Hunter Pence (keeper)
util - Mark Reynolds (3rd base)

sp - Cliff Lee (keeper)
sp - Cole Hamels (keeper)
sp - Josh Beckett (keeper)
sp - Trevor Cahill
rp - Andrew Baily (keeper)
rp - Chris Perez
rp - Evan Meek
p - Adoldis Chapman (keeper)
p - Matt Garza

bench - Travis Snider ( lf / rf )
bench - Ryan Raburn ( 2nd base , lf . cf. rf )
bench - Coco Crsip (cf )
bench - Alcides Escobar ( ss )
bench - Octavio Dotel ( rp )
bench - Alexi Ogando ( rp )
bench- Juan Rivera ( 1st, lf, rf )

[MadDog36]

Jeter himself is on the decline, and Peralta makes for a nice sleeper this year capable of a 270/25/90 season and for a SS you'd take that right. I think he'll even outproduce Jeter this year, who is more name than anything else. Bucholz for basically nothing, do it.

[HOOTIE]

I would do it just for Buchholz alone.
Don't worry about spring stats.
Bob Welch had a 30 era and went on to win 27 that year.

[birdbrains]

who do i drop...
rivera?ogano?

[HOOTIE]

who do i drop...
rivera?ogano?

I wouldn't drop Ogando yet, till they decide on Feliz.
You already have Raburn at CF, i might drop Crisp.
Who knows what Jays are going to do, Francisco is hurting.

[birdbrains]

you think crsip over juan rivera?

crisp was in there for SB support ...
but if u really think crisp is my weak ling then i will do it

so its
perallta and buschollz for jeter and crisp or jeter and j rivera

[HOOTIE]

you think crsip over juan rivera?

crisp was in there for SB support ...
but if u really think crisp is my weak ling then i will do it

so its
perallta and buschollz for jeter and crisp or jeter and j rivera

Rivera, you need the sb.