Jeter or Renteria

[riplycolt]

Who would you rather have on your fantasy team and why. Derek Jeter or Edgar Renteria.

[Big Blue]

Renteria similar numbers if not better then jeter and can be had later usually

[DK]

Take Renteria and run for the hills.

[CrimeDog]

Pretty much a toss up though I'd still lean towards Jeter just because he's a more proven player than renteria.

[fruityloops]

I have Renteria so I might be biased, but I think Renteria will put up better numbers this year.

[warrick95]

Renteria...more RBIs, more SBs...
Jeter...more HRs, more Rs...

In my leagues this year, Jeter has been going AFTER Renteria. I suppose this is due to his injury last year. Thus, perhaps some think he won't steal as much this year as he did in the past. Both ways, I think JETER, not Renteria is actually the better value pick this year. I don't see Renteria repeating with such a high average, though he is still definitely an elite Fantasy SS.

[Pokey Reese MVP]

Renteria is far superior! He is getting better while Jeter is just sitting there, people alway over-value yankees. Jeter is like a name... Renteria is a stud

[BostonBK7]

Renteria

[wrigleyivy]

i actually see jeter having a big year. renteria wont repeat that average. for this year i have jeter above by an inch and a half

[Kevy Kev]

Don't listen to the cubbies fan, I'll take Edgar over Jeter in a heartbeat. Renteria is getting better in his approach at the plate and that's why his average went up last year, I would expect the same if not better this year. I would even expect some more HR's.