Berkman vs. Giles.

[Rob035]

In a standard 5x5 id go with Berkman, but my league counts BBs and Ks, so Giles is more valuable.

[Olsen Triplet]

I think Berkman is going to have a spectacular year.

[DK]

These are one of the pairs that I have trouble separating. I believe Giles has more skill, but that injury plus his subpar play last year is tough. Berkman was also subpar but did deliver. Giles is in a pitcher's park, Berkman in a hitter's haven.

My call? Giles heads, Berkman tails. Best 2 out of 3.

[G-Man]

no more nagging injuries for berkman means he is going to go nuts this season, especially considering manager jim(m)y has said he isnt gonna bump him down in the lineup vs lefties this year.....he's my pick, especially for 4th-5th round value in many drafts