Casey Or BJ?

[brenzie]

My keepers due this weekend and must decide between these two. H2H and down to this question. All things being equal, who would you rather keep:

Casey McGehee or BJ Upton?

If I keep BJ I get SB's and maybe power.
If I keep Casey I get power in scarce position.
If I keep BJ I get possible upside.
If I keep Casey I get a notch above average but no upside.

Who would you keep?

Thanks

[Fenris-77]

I have McGehee ranked slightly ahead of BJ, but a lot depends on your league settings and your other keepers.

[brenzie]

This is a 10 team H2H and my other keepers are:

M Cabrera
F Hernandez
Pedroia
Bell
Heyward
Fielder

Got my last pick narrowed between McGehee or BJ. Upton. Which one??

[nyy28]

I would probably keep them both and throw back Bell. Both of these guys are more valuable than a closer in a 10 team h2h

[Pokeyouindaeye]

I'd probably keep BJ. Hopefully he can keep his average somewhat respectable.

[Guzman24]

I would probably keep them both and throw back Bell. Both of these guys are more valuable than a closer in a 10 team h2h

I agree with this. I'm sure you could replace Bell quite easily at your draft in a 10 team league.

I would keep Casey and BJ

Check mine?
viewtopic.php?t=424358

[rukus9]

I would go with Upton

[BigLebowski]

I would probably keep them both and throw back Bell. Both of these guys are more valuable than a closer in a 10 team h2h

I agree with this. I'm sure you could replace Bell quite easily at your draft in a 10 team league.

I would keep Casey and BJ

Check mine?
viewtopic.php?t=424358

x2 Never keep a closer in 10 team h2h. There are too many closers available and they only help in one category.