McCutchen / J Upton / Choo / Heyward - Rank Them.

[Doughhead]

Having trouble ranking these OFs, so I turn to my Cafe brothers. This is an OPS league, if that changes anything.

[raiders_umpire]

Upton
Heyward
McCutchen
Choo

[cs3]

depends if its a keeper league or not, but if its just for this year then i say:

Choo
Heyward
McCutch
Upton

with Heyward/McC being pretty even but Choo clearly #1 and Upton last.


any help here?
viewtopic.php?f=26&t=424238

[Doughhead]

Funny. Two responses, two completely opposite rankings. No wonder I'm having trouble with this group.

[Skimo77]

#1 Choo
#2 Heyward
#3 Upton
#4 McCutchen

[Whalewang]

These guys are way to closely grouped for a good discussion about them. just throw the names in a hat and that order is probably fine.

.. but I'd say:
McClutch
Choo
Heyward
Upton

My perception is that Heyward and Upton are more brittle than than the other two. If they were all guaranteed 162 games I'd probably inverse the order.

[billycent]

agreed... they are all very good and you will prob be happy w/any of them. But just to pick the best of the bunch... Shin-Soo Choo. Take a look at mine.

viewtopic.php?t=424266

[Fenris-77]

Upton
Heyward
McCutcheon
Choo

As mentioned, they're all pretty close together, especially the top three guys there, whom I have ranked almost next to one another in the middle to late 20's, with Choo about 10 picks later.