Rasmus/Butler for Davis/Young

[CPDirts]

Looking for some trade thoughts here, not sure if this offer will do more damage to my team than good. Been offered Chris Young (ARI) and Ike Davis for Rasmus and Butler. Thinking Young has more long-term value than either Rasmus or Butler, but just not positive. Any thoughts out there on this offer would be appreciated.

My team:
C Miguel Montero, Ari C
1B Billy Butler, KC 1B, DH
2B Gordon Beckham, CWS 2B
3B Ian Stewart, Col 3B
SS Elvis Andrus, Tex SS
2B/SS Neil Walker, Pit 2B
1B/3B Gaby Sanchez, Fla 1B
LF Seth Smith, Col LF, RF
CF Colby Rasmus, StL CF
RF Corey Hart, Mil RF
OF Justin Upton, Ari RF
UTIL Austin Jackson, Det CF
P Madison Bumgarner, SF SP
P Chris Perez, Cle RP
P Craig Kimbrel, Atl RP
SP Colby Lewis, Tex SP
SP Cliff Lee, Phi SP
SP Matt Cain, SF SP
SP Wandy Rodriguez, Hou SP
RP Ryan Franklin, StL RP
RP Jonny Venters, Atl RP
Bench Starlin Castro, ChC SS
Bench Edwin Encarnacion, Tor 3B
Bench Jorge De La Rosa, Col SP
Bench Ben Francisco, Phi LF, RF

Batting - AVG, HR, R, RBI, SB, SLG, OBP, TB, K, BB, AST, FPCT
Pitching - ERA, K, WHIP, W, SV, QS, HR, HD, IP, BB, BS, K/BB

[avsfan4ever33]

I'd pass - I like both players you're giving up more than the counterparts you're receiving.

[dave knight]

No. butler better than Davis, Young equal to Rasmus. No profit here.

[CPDirts]

The other owner also proposed Young straight up for Rasmus, but my gut feeling says its not worth it.

Also thanks for the answers guys (or gals).

[BigLebowski]

I'm much higher on Young than it seems, well everybody. I'd take Young for Rasmus every stinkin day of the week. I wouldn't trade Butler for Davis though. If you can get away with a straight up deal then I'd take it.