Zobrist for Lind (Keeper League) WHIR

[eaglesfan]

Would you do it?



12 Teams - Keepers - Rotisserie

Roster Positions: C, C, 1B, 2B, 3B, SS, CI, MI, OF, OF, OF, OF, OF, Util, P, P, P, P, P, P, P, P, P, BN, BN, BN, BN, BN, DL, DL, DL
Batters Stat Categories: Runs (R), Home Runs (HR), Runs Batted In (RBI), Stolen Bases (SB), On-base + Slugging Percentage (OPS)
Pitchers Stat Categories: Wins (W), Saves (SV), Strikeouts (K), Earned Run Average (ERA), (Walks + Hits)/ Innings Pitched (WHIP)

Lineup:
C - Y. Molina
C - A. Avila
1B - Zobrist
2B - Wiggington
3B - Zimmerman
SS - S. Drew
CI - Loney
MI - Aviles
OF - Ethier
OF - Kemp
OF - McCutchen
OF - DeJesus
OF - Matsui
Util - Barton
BN - Y. Escobar
BN - C. Johnson
BN - M. Trout

SP - F. Hernandez
SP - R. Romero
SP - F. Liriano
SP - J. Garcia
SP - T. Cahill
P - R. Soriano
P - Kuo
P - Zambrano
P - Braden
BN - F. Rodney
BN- F. Francisco

[avsfan4ever33]

I'd stand pat on both offers. I'm simply not a fan of Ichiro, especially in a keeper league.

[dave knight]

That's a good deal to me. (the ethier deal).

[Skimo77]

Ethier trade yes. Kemp trade no.

[HOOTIE]

I'd stand pat on both offers. I'm simply not a fan of Ichiro, especially in a keeper league.

[eaglesfan]

So he came back with another deal....


Kemp
Zobrist

for


Kendry Morales
Adam Lind
Logan Morrison


I'm thinking no...thoughts? Thanks for the responses thus far.

[emenewe5]

I'd leave all three on the table. I'm not sold on Ike Davis (and don't look at him as a big upgrade for you anywhere) and I'd MUCH rather have Ethier or Kemp over Ichiro in your format, IMO.

I'd target an upgrade at C and 2B, if I'm you. I'd have Loney starting at 1B and then target the best available CI (which could be Zobrist or Wiggy maybe...but...I'd keep my eyes open for upgrades there too).

I'd be tempted to shop Kemp "some". I think he's slightly overrated and if you can get someone to overpay, then great. But, I don't think you're in a position that you need to make wholesale changes or anything.

[eaglesfan]

I'd leave all three on the table. I'm not sold on Ike Davis (and don't look at him as a big upgrade for you anywhere) and I'd MUCH rather have Ethier or Kemp over Ichiro in your format, IMO.

I'd target an upgrade at C and 2B, if I'm you. I'd have Loney starting at 1B and then target the best available CI (which could be Zobrist or Wiggy maybe...but...I'd keep my eyes open for upgrades there too).

I'd be tempted to shop Kemp "some". I think he's slightly overrated and if you can get someone to overpay, then great. But, I don't think you're in a position that you need to make wholesale changes or anything.

He actually came back with a Lind for Zobrist?

[emenewe5]

Lind is at that prime age and has better upside. The equalizer is Zobrist's eligibility at 2B. Tough call. If Zobrist is your 2B, you should have a top-10 2B. If you're playing him at 1B or OF, I'd rather have Lind.

(Help with my Prade/Utley issue?! Thanks!)

[eaglesfan]

Lind is at that prime age and has better upside. The equalizer is Zobrist's eligibility at 2B. Tough call. If Zobrist is your 2B, you should have a top-10 2B. If you're playing him at 1B or OF, I'd rather have Lind.

(Help with my Prade/Utley issue?! Thanks!)

Probably stick Zobrist at 2B at the moment.

I could put Lind at 1B, Loney and CI and Wiggy at 2B(till I upgrade) if I do the deal.

I guess the question is, how much of a drop is Wiggy at 2B compared to Zobrist?