Trade Help !!! Lester/JJ for Votto/Hamels

[rookie58]

I'm in a 12 team keeper, standard 5X5 scoring. We keep 6 keeper (3bats 3 pitchers) over last couple yrs i've compiled f.hernandez, j.lester, and j.johnson as my 3 keeper pitchers. NOT BAD !! BUT i need a big bat. What would you do?? Lester/JJ for Votto/Hamels ?? The rest of my SP's this yr. b.morrow, b.anderson, j.zimmerman, b.cecil and a.chapman Any help would be appreciated WHIR

[rukus9]

Looks like a pretty solid deal to me. Who is on first for you now?

[rookie58]

Guess that would help !! i've got Youk on 1st, m.young on 3rd. my thoughts are to put Youk at 3rd and votto at 1st, dangle young in another trade or utl/fill in

[rukus9]

Would there be someone else interested in Young? If you could deal Young and another pitcher to get a higher end pitcher I would be all for it. I would try and have someone lined up to take Young first though if you could.

[SCOTTYG]

Yes, I would do that trade. I think Youk could bring you more in return than Young in a trade.

[HOOTIE]

Votto side

[BigLebowski]

Yeah I'd take the Votto side without any regrets.