Josh Hamilton for Andrew McCutchen Trade

[rasto21585]

in my 16 team h2h dynasty league I was just offered josh hamilton for andrew mccutchen. Should I make this deal?


c jp arencibia
1b justin morneau
2b howie kendrick
3b chase headley
ss alcides escobar
of jason heyward
of andrew mccutchen
of colby rasmus
util brennan boesch
util juan piere
bn eric young
bn mike trout
bn jesus montero
bn chris carter


sp clayton kershaw
sp felix hernandez
rp fernando rodney
rp brandon league
p brett anderson
p jaime garcia
p daniel hudson
p rick porcello
bn bud norris
bn clayton richard
bn alfredo simon

[HighHeater]

no way

Josh is always injured(last year was lucky), hes older then McCutchen and McCutchen is on the rise(crawford type ceiling imo)

[SCOTTYG]

I agree about the potential of McCutchen, and even if Hamilton goes down, his stats will still be better by years end. Take the best player.

[MaudDib]

Keep McCutchen. We have no idea which Hamilton we are going to get this year, 09 or 10. Probably a little of both but again no way to know. McCutchen is still very young and should continue to get better. And as the Pirates get better (which their offense is looking better) then his numbers should really improve.