Which 2 keepers would you choose? (First-timer here)

[Buttermilk Pancake]

I've narrowed my keepers down to the following four players. Which two would you keep?

Mat Latos [7th Round]
Jered Weaver [10th Round]
Max Scherzer [14th Round]
Ike Davis [18th Round]

Thanks!!

[down.by.law]

Do you have any other keepers? Who else is on your team? Either way I'd be keeping:

Jered Weaver (as a 10th Round pick)

[Buttermilk Pancake]

Thanks for your help! By the way, this is a 12 team H2H, standard 5x5 + Total Bases and Quality Starts.

I am allowed *up to* three keepers, but I don't have to take all three. I am definitely keeping Buster Posey [19th Round].

My other options are:

Round / Player (from my original draft last year--I would keep them from the round I drafted them in)
1 M. Teixeira
2 T. Tulowitski
3 M. Reynolds
4 B. McCann
5 B. Roberts
6 A. Hill
7 W. Rodriguez
8 M. Ramirez
9 N. McLouth
10 J. Weaver
11 G. Jones
12 M. Cuddyer
13 S. Kazmir
14. M. Scherzer
15 J. Piniero
16 JP Howell
17 M. Derosa
18 J. Frasor
20 R. Furcal

or, mid-seaon pickups. (I would draft them for the round according to their Yahoo ranking. For instance N. Feliz is ranked #70, so he would be my 6th round pick)

A. Torres
B. Lyon
C. McGehee
C. Crisp
C. Hart
J. Bay
J. Garland
M. Capps
M. Latos
I. Davis
N. Feliz
R. Raburn
S. Marcum
S. Drew
T. Hanson

[down.by.law]

Weaver and Posey for sure. If you want to choose another, go with Tulo in the 2nd, just to have a SS locked up.

[HOOTIE]

Weaver and Posey for sure. If you want to choose another, go with Tulo in the 2nd, just to have a SS locked up.

[LeftyQB]

I'd keep Posey, Weaver and definitely Tulo. He's a top 5 pick and definitely worth a 2nd rounder.

[Cream]

I'd keep Posey, Weaver and definitely Tulo. He's a top 5 pick and definitely worth a 2nd rounder.

Ditto

[Buttermilk Pancake]

Thanks for the help everyone!

[raiders_umpire]

I'd keep Posey, Weaver and definitely Tulo. He's a top 5 pick and definitely worth a 2nd rounder.