Adrian/elsbury for Longoria/heyward???

[amarlls]

Should I so this trade in a 5x5 roto 10 team league with the players I got? Ive got Miggy at 1st and can plug longoria in at 3rd and switch from mcgehee and freese at CI. Is Adrian to big to lose this year being in that ballpark?

Active Batters
Montero, Miguel(C) ARI
Posada, Jorge(C) NYY
Cabrera, Miguel(1B) DET
Phillips, Brandon(2B) CIN
McGehee, Casey(3B) MIL
Reyes, Jose(SS) NYM
Roberts, Brian(2B) BAL
Gonzalez, Adrian(1B) BOS
Ellsbury, Jacoby(OF) BOS
Kemp, Matt(OF) LA
McCutchen, Andrew(OF) PIT
Ordonez, Magglio(OF) DET
Tabata, Jose(OF) PIT
Loney, James(1B) LA

Freese, David(3B) STL
Snider, Travis(OF) TOR

Rankings
Active Pitchers
Aardsma, David(P) SEA
Billingsley, Chad(P) LA
Broxton, Jonathan(P) LA
Cain, Matt(P) SF
Latos, Mat(P) SD
Lilly, Ted(P) LA
Marcum, Shaun(P) MIL
Sanchez, Jonathan(P) SF
Thornton, Matt(P) CHW

Duensing, Brian(P) MIN
Peavy, Jake(P) CHW
Pineda, Michael(P) SEA
Webb, Brandon(P) TEX

[avsfan4ever33]

I wouldn't hesitate to make this deal. I think Longo has a slight edge on A-Gon, and I prefer Heyward by a lot to Ellsbury.

[ryetoast93]

Accept this fast. Longo is probably a bit better than Gonzalez, plus you already have Miggy. What's more, Heyward is a big upgrade over Ellsbury. Take it and run.

[HOOTIE]

I wouldn't hesitate to make this deal. I think Longo has a slight edge on A-Gon, and I prefer Heyward by a lot to Ellsbury.

[down.by.law]

Make the deal!! Longoria and Miggy are as good as it gets at the corners and Ellsbury's talent could be found much later in the draft...

Mine:
viewtopic.php?t=423898