I get Posey ($15) for Reynolds ($45) and Kershaw ($85)

[Moss84]

I have been offered Buster Posey ($15) for Mark Reynolds ($45) and Clayton Kershaw ($85) or Cole Hamels ($75). Basically divide prices by 4 for $260 leagues.

12 team H2h Mixed League: $1000 cap and draft 24 players

I can keep 5 players: 1 Infield, 1 Outfield, 1 SP and 2 final keepers from any position.

I'm leaning toward keeping Tulowitzki ($70), Utley ($95) - not 100% depending on injury update, McCutchen ($65), and need to decide on Pitcher (Price, Hamels, Kershaw) and final keeper (Reynolds, Mauer, Kemp, Pence).

Scoring:
Hitters - 1 pt per Hit, run, rbi, sb, bb, hbp. 2B= 2 pts, 3B=3pts, HR=4 pts
Pitchers - Basically WINS and K's : 10 pts a win, -5 a loss, 1 per K , 5 pts for CG, 5 pts for Shutout - NO ERA, WHIP etc.

I can keep 5 players: 1 Infield, 1 Outfield, 1 SP and 2 final keepers from any position
My Potential Keepers:
Mauer - $110 - best catcher but high price
Tulowitzki - $70 (no brainer)
Utley - $95 (Cano is being kept at $130) - Injury scares me but still decent value
Mark Reynolds - $45 - down 2010 season but good price and Baltimore good home hitters park (wright, beltre, zimmerman, longoria will all be kept). Bounce back potential ?
McCutchen - $65 - definitely keeping him
Pence - $60 - weak supporting cast but reaching prime years.
Matt Kemp - $105 - can he rebound knowing he'll be hitting cleanupVictorino - $40

Pitchers: (wins and K's most important)
David Price - $50 - Rays loss of Crawford/Pena/ Soriano - less wins for Price ?
Cole Hamels - $75
Clayton Kershaw - $85
Ted Lilly - $15
Brett Myers - $15 - was great last season and potential trade to Yankees


I'll answer yours.

[pizzaboy76]

I would do that trade. Posey solidifies a weak position for cheap and I like him more than Reynolds and his .220 avg.

You also have the pitching to compensate for losing Kershaw, most likely Price or Hamels.

Please help;

viewtopic.php?t=423624

[Moss84]

any other insights ? Other team wants Hamels and Reynolds and I get Posey.

[ayebatter]

Reynolds and his .220 avg.

Reynolds will give you a combined 45 hr/sb and 180+ r/rbi, who cares about the average in h2h.