3 for 3

[HOOTIE]

Keeper league with 13 keepers. Which 3 do you prefer?

A AGon, Kemp, McCann

B Howard, Holliday, Posey

[oldmanbean]

Keeper league with 13 keepers. Which 3 do you prefer?

A AGon, Kemp, McCann

B Howard, Holliday, Posey

Gun to my head, B, but if I could I would swap AGon with Howard first

Help?

http://www.fantasybaseballcafe.com/forums/viewtopic.php?t=423298

[HOOTIE]

bump

[Pogotheostrich]

I'll take A. Adrian over Howard. Kemp vs. Holliday is a tossup for this year but Kemp is younger so I go Kemp in a keeper. Posey vs. McCann is pretty close too for this year too. I actually like McCann more than most. Posey is the play in a keeper but I'll take 2 out of 3 with A.

[Giambis]

I'll take A. Adrian over Howard. Kemp vs. Holliday is a tossup for this year but Kemp is younger so I go Kemp in a keeper. Posey vs. McCann is pretty close too for this year too. I actually like McCann more than most. Posey is the play in a keeper but I'll take 2 out of 3 with A.

This. I like Adrian a lot more than Howard than a keeper, which much more than makes up for the slight edge I give to Holliday over Kemp. And I love McCann, have him in my keeper league and he's been as consistent as they come, which I value over Posey's (admittedly tantalizing) upside. If you want upside, Team A gives you that through Kemp and Gonzalez.

[MadDog36]

Tough: A AGon, Kemp, McCann

[Seanyfever]

A Gon swings this for me, and I do think Posey will not live up to expectations this year, and McCann is McCann.

Looking for your return input....
viewtopic.php?f=26&t=423395&p=3357373#p3357373

[lbblue]

Probably A...barely.

[The Artful Dodger]

Side A for me. I prefer A-Gon over Howard which just about clinches it for me. I'd rather have Holliday over Kemp, but Kemp is a more preferable keeper especially if he rebounds (confident it will happen). I'd give the edge to McCann over Posey for now.